RSS

Thu, Nov 6th 2008, 08:31

Patrick Edwin Moran, Wake Forest University, Platinum Contributor (201)

The author's analysis is in general well formulated and useful. However, the wish that the U.S. might provide resources for the repair of local deficiencies that promote basing of terrorist forces in these areas may lead to Pakistan's own failure to take the essential steps needed to resolve problems on its own. How much could be accomplished if the government of Pakistan were to provide substantial resources to the people of the so-called frontier area on a par with the rest of that country? Securing the allegiance of people in such a domain requires the provision of schools, public health services, roads, and other such infrastructure elements, and making it clear that these are benefits resulting from being a real part of Pakistan. Attempting merely to procure "law and order" will fail regardless of whether the effort comes from Pakistan or from frustrated military forces in Afghanistan.

Thu, Nov 6th 2008, 14:01

Donald Stadler, Self-employed, Diamond Contributor (1052)

I am uncomfortable with the direction UP policy is taking here. The cross-border strikes are a decision which should be left to the next president. I've agreed with Bush on much over the past decade but cannot agree with this.