Issues Navigator

Global Challenges

Strategic Regions

Domestic Debates

Tag cloud

See All Tags

April 29, 2010 |  8 comments |  Print | E-Mail Your Research  

MA Thesis: What Role Does India Have in the War on Terrorism?

Kerley Tolpolar: The westernized classes targeted by Mumbai’s attackers and the part played by Lashkar-e-Tayyiba, and its backers in Pakistan, gave rise to voices calling for India to reconsider its non-aligned mentality and join in the global fight against the jihadist movement.

In 2008, India ranked among the world’s most terrorism-afflicted countries according to U.S. State Department’s Country Reports on Terrorism. The country was the focus of numerous attacks from both externally-based terrorist organizations and internally-based separatist or terrorist entities. Several attacks inflicted large numbers of casualties, including the most devastating attack of the year on November 26 in Mumbai. At least 183 people were killed, including 22 foreigners, six of whom were Americans and 14 members of the police and security forces. Over 300 more were injured. The assaults in Mumbai targeted places frequented by foreigners and wealthy Indians. The perpetrators entered the city from the sea and attacked people in two hotels, a Jewish center, the main train station, and additional locations. They also planted bombs in two taxis that later exploded in different locations in the city. The terrorists appeared to have been well trained and took advantage of technology, such as Global Positioning System trackers. Local and state police proved to be poorly trained and equipped, and lacked central control to coordinate an effective response.

The terror attacks shifted India’s fight against terrorism from regional to international level. For many years India has fought terrorist-style violence in the disputed territory of Kashmir, but Mumbai globalized this fight and has drawn the country into the center of the war on terror. Lashkar-e-Tayyiba, one of the groups the Indian government believes was behind the Mumbai attacks, is among several banned Pakistani militant groups that experts say received backing from Pakistan’s intelligence agency to fight in Indian-administered Kashmir. Analysts say the group continues to operate freely inside Pakistan under a different name and has now become a global terrorist organization.

Kerley Tolpolar is a graduate student, majoring in Security and Intelligence Studies, at the School of Public and International Affairs, University of Pittsburgh.

 
  • 2
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this Article! What's this?

 
 
Comments
Olga  Kolesnichenko

April 29, 2010

  • 1
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Absolutely maintain the author's opinion that is very relevant in terms of fast growing of Indo-Pacific Region. India isn't only the biggest population but it is the nuclear club member. The tension in region and the deeper invasion into region of international terroristic organizatios - in particular theirs escape from AfPak to Indo-Pacific Region - must be considered among Euro-Atlantic community. If we look at map, we will see that there are gathering almost all of nuclear club members - Russian Far East, China, India, Pakistan, North Korea. So, it looks like boiling place that isn't under NATO control yet. And in comparison with NATO, Indo-Pacific Region may become like 'real elephant in the porcelain shop'.
On the site of Brussels Forum was published the report 'As Asia Rises How the West can enlarge its community of values and interests in the Indo-Pacific Region' by Daniel Twining, The German Marshall Fund of the United States.
www.brusselsforum.org. /> http://www.gmfus.org/brusselsforum/2010/agenda.html
 
Kazimierz  Wiesak

May 3, 2010

  • 2
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Terrorism is a war of powerless and desperate against all powerful.
So, war on terrorism is a war on war.
Orwell said that we'll have war for peace. He was wrong, we have something even worse, war on war.
Tags: | terrorism |
 
Unregistered User

May 3, 2010

  • 2
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
India is an impoverished, complex, and diverse nation with huge cleavages in society. One part of India is "shining" and a much larger other part finds people live in dire poverty without the basic necessities of life such as adquate nutrition, food, shelter, clean water supply, and healthcare. The country has suffered from violent armed struggles waged by ethnic and peasant groups. Prime MInister Manmohan Singh has recently proclaimed that the greatest danger facing India the Maoist insurgency, which is based primarily in the extremely poor and undeveloped tribal areas.
These insurgencies have exsited for decades much before the term "terrorism" or "war on terror" enetered the lexicon of the western analysts. Kerley Tolpolar writes as if the concept of "war on terror", let alone the war itself is univerally accepted. India is home to nearly 150 million Muslims - the second largest in the world. The two communities majority Hindus and Muslims have lived in relative harmony despite occsaional bllodletting. Contrary to her thesis majority of Indians see Bush and now Obama's war on terror as misguided and there is very little support to join it full bore. As the experiences in Iraq and Afghanistan have shown, it has been a costly and failed strategy. It is not the "non-aligned mentality" that is keeping India from waging just a military war, but the resilience of its people and perhaps its democracy, however flawed.
 
Unregistered User

May 6, 2010

  • 3
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
26/11 proved that Terror organisations involved in Afpak regions are active for almost two decades and mostly ignored by western powers from long ( everybody knows about Attacks in Kashmir in 90's and Western views about that ).Remember Ronald Reagan praised mujahideen as "freedom fighters". India and Israil faces similar Geography Situations
Everybody knows Pakisthan's Democratic Govt. support to Taliban. American dollars changed there views for while now Euros going follow who ends up buying Weapons to attack India ( by any means ).Indians are Secular; Peaceful n Progressive plus highly influenced by western Cultures thats why we been disliked n attacked frequently.
Indians and Foreigner ( Eu / Americans) as a combined target with similar ideology and cultures. India doesn't go on war after 26/11 Since that will divert Taliban towards India then Pakistan.
Kerley, your view about Security is Moderately true but no country civilian Police is trained to fight commando trained and well equipped guys like these. India fighting all alone all these decades seen some really ignorant view in last decades. searching 1989-1990 Kashmir Insurgency in google will tell you the Inability of Govt. similar to yours can do when Civilized Society Been attacked . what NATO is following is non-aligned in 90's to aligned when things come to themselves.What they doing to deal with POK's terror Camps nothing.. non-aligned NATO.
Do you have Police in Europe trained how to deal with Automatic riffle and Grande Launcher
@Subrata
India has Union govt. not federal results in Undeveloped central India n Maoist.
@Kerley It was always international some people don't care till fire reach there backyard.things starts from Ideas. We have to force Pakisthan to Takes some real action against terror Infra . developed from long.Money cant Solves the problem we have to force them to do that..What your Subtitle is one Sided view of Map.
 
Unregistered User

September 27, 2010

  • 1
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Terrorist attacks on civilian targets & killing of unarmed/non combatant /innocent people any where in the world including Mumbai can not be approved by any religion, ethics or belief & these acts must be condemned by all means. Thus India deserve our full sympathy.
However, the civilized/developed world must go beyond sympathy & reflect on the the causes of terrorism. The world history shows that the weak & oppressed resorted to the acts of violence & achieved the impossible, where the religion may play a motivating factor but acts of violence may not be bounded by any norms. Therefore; it may be emphasized that real causes (injustices/oppression etc) may be addressed to curb violence now being called terrorism). I think until & unless the root causes of terrorism are squarely addressed by the civilized/developed world, especially by the Indians, this menace will never be controlled. In India; the oppression of ethnic/religious minorities by superior Hindu classes may be the real causes of violence & it must be curbed/fought through strict measures, education of the society & through the power propaganda on media. The real solution lies in collective harmony & not by elimination of one class/religious community by the other
 
Unregistered User

October 21, 2010

  • 0
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
@Zamash
As far as modern history in concerned , There is no direct link between Economically poor Pakistani Terrorists and India as a nation.Only terrorist which remained alive, Kasab came from rural Pakistani village.Taking a view of Kasab concern with Indian oppression as Village boy is disguising World into whole new dimensions. Pakistan is self deteriorating nation which cannot sustain itself without America,If they didn't find Hindus/Jews/Christean's to kill they will kill each other , as we are seeing these days.
Pakistan is a Islamic nation,oppression by Non-Muslim peoples cannot be imagined.
 
Unregistered User

June 12, 2011

  • 0
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
The more pertinent issue is: how does India define itself? After so many decades of having achieved independence, the issue over an Indian state remains unresolved. Even though its constitution is modern in its inception and still continues over and with that framework. That is one question that the Indian political class needs to address first (without imagining that they form the epitome of modernity & average intelligence amongst the Indians or that every Indian is born stupid; is medieval; and genetically pre-disposed to crime & violence). The need for any state to achieve a clarity over the meaning of its existence as well as the nature of its existence is crucial. India and Indians need to achieve that minimum clarity. Once done, rest becomes easier.
 
Talha Bin  Tariq

January 17, 2012

  • 0
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Several attacks inflicted large numbers of casualties, including the most devastating attack of the year on November 26 in Mumbai. At least 183 people were killed, including 22 foreigners, six of whom were Americans and 14 members of the police and security forces. Over 300 more were injured. The assaults in Mumbai targeted places frequented by foreigners and wealthy Indians. The perpetrators entered the city from the sea and attacked people in two hotels, a Jewish center, the main train station, and additional locations. They also planted bombs in two taxis that later exploded in different locations in the city. The terrorists appeared to have been well trained and took advantage of technology, such as Global Positioning System trackers. Local and state police proved to be poorly trained and equipped, and lacked central control to coordinate an effective response.


After this terrorism attack .. blame was given to Pakistan ..
But when Pakistan get under attack by different terrorism activities ..
Whom should be blame ?

I believe its our governments who have been failed to minimize the terrorists activities in these both countries for their own benefits.

Regards,
Talha Bin Tariq
 

Create Comment

Type the characters shown in the image below into the textfield.
Captcha

What are tags?

Community

Jobs / Internships

Call for Papers

Atlantic Events

Partners

User of the day

Anna  Przybyll
Anna Przybyll
"A wise old owl lived in an oak The more he..."

Poll

Should NATO intervene in Syria?